» Premier League + 1. Division Solo Premier League
 
# Jugador Equipo(s) Penaltis
101 John Hollins Chelsea Chelsea
Arsenal Arsenal
Queens Park Rangers Queens Park Rangers
14
Leighton James Derby County Derby County
Sunderland Sunderland
Queens Park Rangers Queens Park Rangers
Swansea City Swansea City
Burnley FC Burnley FC
14
Jimmy Langley Fulham FC Fulham FC
14
Terry McDermott Newcastle United Newcastle United
Liverpool Liverpool
14
Bobby Mitchell Newcastle United Newcastle United
14
Gary Owen West Bromwich Albion West Bromwich Albion
Manchester City Manchester City
14
Michael Owen Manchester United Manchester United
Newcastle United Newcastle United
Liverpool Liverpool
Stoke City Stoke City
14
Joe Royle Everton Everton
Norwich City Norwich City
Manchester City Manchester City
Bristol City Bristol City
14
109 Clive Allen Chelsea Chelsea
Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
West Ham United West Ham United
Queens Park Rangers Queens Park Rangers
Manchester City Manchester City
Crystal Palace Crystal Palace
13
Mick Channon Southampton Southampton
Norwich City Norwich City
Manchester City Manchester City
13
Mick Coop Coventry City Coventry City
13
Johnny Hancocks Wolverhampton Wanderers Wolverhampton Wanderers
13
Gordon Hodgson Leeds United Leeds United
Liverpool Liverpool
Aston Villa Aston Villa
13
Joshua King * Watford FC Watford FC
Bournemouth Bournemouth
13
Riyad Mahrez * Leicester City Leicester City
Manchester City Manchester City
13
Brian Marwood Arsenal Arsenal
Sheffield Wednesday Sheffield Wednesday
Sheffield United Sheffield United
13
Benni McCarthy Blackburn Rovers Blackburn Rovers
13
Andy McCluggage Burnley FC Burnley FC
13
Graeme Sharp Everton Everton
Oldham Athletic Oldham Athletic
13
Carlos Tévez Manchester United Manchester United
West Ham United West Ham United
Manchester City Manchester City
13
Roy Wegerle Chelsea Chelsea
Blackburn Rovers Blackburn Rovers
Queens Park Rangers Queens Park Rangers
Coventry City Coventry City
Luton Town Luton Town
13
122 Steve Bruce Manchester United Manchester United
Norwich City Norwich City
12
Billy Clunas Sunderland Sunderland
12
John Deehan Aston Villa Aston Villa
Norwich City Norwich City
West Bromwich Albion West Bromwich Albion
12
Bryan Douglas Blackburn Rovers Blackburn Rovers
12
Gordon Harris Sunderland Sunderland
Burnley FC Burnley FC
12
Andy Johnson Fulham FC Fulham FC
Everton Everton
Crystal Palace Crystal Palace
12
Frank Mountford Stoke City Stoke City
12
Louis Saha Manchester United Manchester United
Newcastle United Newcastle United
Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
Fulham FC Fulham FC
Everton Everton
12
Gylfi Sigurðsson * Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
Everton Everton
Swansea City Swansea City
12
Peter Sillett Chelsea Chelsea
12
Joe Smith Bolton Wanderers Bolton Wanderers
12
Danny Wilson Nottingham Forest Nottingham Forest
Sheffield Wednesday Sheffield Wednesday
Luton Town Luton Town
12
134 Charlie Adam Liverpool Liverpool
Stoke City Stoke City
Blackpool FC Blackpool FC
11
Danny Blanchflower Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
Aston Villa Aston Villa
11
Stan Bowles Nottingham Forest Nottingham Forest
Queens Park Rangers Queens Park Rangers
Manchester City Manchester City
11
Ray Charnley Blackpool FC Blackpool FC
11
Norman Curtis Sheffield Wednesday Sheffield Wednesday
11
Lee Dixon Arsenal Arsenal
11
Keith Eddy Sheffield United Sheffield United
11
Gerry Francis Queens Park Rangers Queens Park Rangers
Coventry City Coventry City
Crystal Palace Crystal Palace
11
Ted Harper Blackburn Rovers Blackburn Rovers
Sheffield Wednesday Sheffield Wednesday
11
Ernie Hine Leicester City Leicester City
Huddersfield Town Huddersfield Town
11
Tommy Law Chelsea Chelsea
11
Jimmy McIlroy Stoke City Stoke City
Burnley FC Burnley FC
11
Kevin Phillips Southampton Southampton
Sunderland Sunderland
Aston Villa Aston Villa
Birmingham City Birmingham City
11
Thomas Ritchie Sunderland Sunderland
Bristol City Bristol City
11
Ivan Toney * Brentford FC Brentford FC
11
Yaya Touré Manchester City Manchester City
11
Jon Walters Stoke City Stoke City
11
* Jugador en activo