Premier League + 1. Division » Solo Premier League
 
# Jugador Equipo(s) Penaltis
1 Alan Shearer Newcastle United Newcastle United
Blackburn Rovers Blackburn Rovers
54
2 Frank Lampard Chelsea Chelsea
West Ham United West Ham United
Manchester City Manchester City
43
3 Mohamed Salah * Chelsea Chelsea
Liverpool Liverpool
34
4 Harry Kane * Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
33
5 Steven Gerrard Liverpool Liverpool
31
6 Mark Noble West Ham United West Ham United
28
7 Sergio Agüero Manchester City Manchester City
27
Jamie Vardy * Leicester City Leicester City
27
9 Matt Le Tissier Southampton Southampton
24
10 Wayne Rooney Manchester United Manchester United
Everton Everton
23
11 Bruno Fernandes * Manchester United Manchester United
22
Thierry Henry Arsenal Arsenal
22
Luka Milivojević * Crystal Palace Crystal Palace
22
14 Leighton Baines Everton Everton
Wigan Athletic Wigan Athletic
20
David Unsworth West Ham United West Ham United
Everton Everton
Portsmouth FC Portsmouth FC
Wigan Athletic Wigan Athletic
20
16 Jorginho * Chelsea Chelsea
19
Teddy Sheringham Manchester United Manchester United
Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
West Ham United West Ham United
Nottingham Forest Nottingham Forest
Portsmouth FC Portsmouth FC
19
18 Yakubu Ayegbeni Middlesbrough Middlesbrough
Blackburn Rovers Blackburn Rovers
Everton Everton
Portsmouth FC Portsmouth FC
18
Gareth Barry Aston Villa Aston Villa
Everton Everton
West Bromwich Albion West Bromwich Albion
Manchester City Manchester City
18
Troy Deeney Watford FC Watford FC
18
Gary McAllister Leeds United Leeds United
Liverpool Liverpool
Coventry City Coventry City
18
Danny Murphy Liverpool Liverpool
Charlton Athletic Charlton Athletic
Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
Fulham FC Fulham FC
18
23 Peter Beardsley Newcastle United Newcastle United
Bolton Wanderers Bolton Wanderers
Everton Everton
17
Darren Bent Sunderland Sunderland
Charlton Athletic Charlton Athletic
Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
Ipswich Town Ipswich Town
Fulham FC Fulham FC
Aston Villa Aston Villa
17
Robbie Fowler Leeds United Leeds United
Liverpool Liverpool
Manchester City Manchester City
17
Erling Haaland * Manchester City Manchester City
17
Eden Hazard Chelsea Chelsea
17
Robbie Keane Leeds United Leeds United
Liverpool Liverpool
Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
West Ham United West Ham United
Aston Villa Aston Villa
Coventry City Coventry City
17
Mikel Arteta Arsenal Arsenal
Everton Everton
17
James Milner * Leeds United Leeds United
Newcastle United Newcastle United
Liverpool Liverpool
Aston Villa Aston Villa
Manchester City Manchester City
17
31 James Beattie Southampton Southampton
Everton Everton
Stoke City Stoke City
16
Ruud van Nistelrooy Manchester United Manchester United
16
Callum Wilson * Newcastle United Newcastle United
Bournemouth Bournemouth
16
Ian Wright West Ham United West Ham United
Arsenal Arsenal
16
35 Paolo Di Canio Charlton Athletic Charlton Athletic
West Ham United West Ham United
Sheffield Wednesday Sheffield Wednesday
15
Julian Dicks Liverpool Liverpool
West Ham United West Ham United
15
Robin van Persie Manchester United Manchester United
Arsenal Arsenal
15
James Ward-Prowse * Southampton Southampton
West Ham United West Ham United
15
39 Éric Cantona Leeds United Leeds United
Manchester United Manchester United
14
Cristiano Ronaldo * Manchester United Manchester United
14
Jermain Defoe Sunderland Sunderland
Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
West Ham United West Ham United
Portsmouth FC Portsmouth FC
Bournemouth Bournemouth
14
Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink Leeds United Leeds United
Chelsea Chelsea
Middlesbrough Middlesbrough
Charlton Athletic Charlton Athletic
14
Michael Owen Manchester United Manchester United
Newcastle United Newcastle United
Liverpool Liverpool
Stoke City Stoke City
14
44 Joshua King * Watford FC Watford FC
Bournemouth Bournemouth
13
Riyad Mahrez * Leicester City Leicester City
Manchester City Manchester City
13
Benni McCarthy Blackburn Rovers Blackburn Rovers
13
Cole Palmer * Chelsea Chelsea
13
Carlos Tévez Manchester United Manchester United
West Ham United West Ham United
Manchester City Manchester City
13
49 Andy Johnson Fulham FC Fulham FC
Everton Everton
Crystal Palace Crystal Palace
12
Louis Saha Manchester United Manchester United
Newcastle United Newcastle United
Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur
Fulham FC Fulham FC
Everton Everton
12
* Jugador en activo